Expert Evidence 2015


Course Date: November 18, 2015

Total: 5h 5min

Welcome and Introduction

Colleen J. Smith — Ministry of Justice, Vancouver Crown Counsel, Vancouver
Graham J. Underwood — Ministry of Justice, Victoria

Expert Evidence: Case Law Update

  • key decisions
  • what you need to know
  • implications for practice

Dianne M. Wiedemann — Ministry of Justice, Crown Law Division, Vancouver
Graham J. Underwood — Ministry of Justice, Victoria

The Role of the Expert Witness

  • is an expert witness necessary?
  • when do you need an expert witness?
  • what is the proper sphere of opinion evidence?
  • the ongoing challenge of novel scientific theories

The Honourable Madam Justice Barbara Fisher — Supreme Court of BC, Vancouver
Richard S. Fowler, QC — Smith and Fowler, Vancouver
Catherine L. Woods, QC — Alexander Holburn Beaudin + Lang LLP, Vancouver

Networking Break

Retaining and Working with Your Expert Witness

  • considerations in choosing an expert
  • the process of retaining your expert
  • managing communications with your expert
  • the expert report

Wendy E. Dawson, QC — Ministry of Justice, New Westminster
Andrew I. Nathanson — Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP, Vancouver

Professional and Ethical Issues around Expert Evidence

  • conflicts of interest
  • confidentiality
  • privilege
  • ethics and instructing your expert
  • ensuring expert independence

David Layton — Ministry of Justice, Crown Law Division, Vancouver 

Networking Lunch 

Admissibility—the Big Issue

  • the test for admissibility
  • the gatekeeper role of the trial judge
  • dealing with novel scientific evidence
  • procedural aspects: civil and criminal

Tracey M. Cohen — Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP, Vancouver
Peter A. Juk, QC — Director, Appeals & Special Prosecutions, Ministry of Justice, Crown Law Division, Vancouver

Examination of Expert Witnesses: Direct and Cross

  • identifying your goals
  • planning your examination
  • conducting your examination
  • knowing when enough is enough

The Honourable Judge James Bahen — Provincial Court of BC, Vancouver
Sandra M. Katalinic — QA Law, Vancouver
Elliot Poll — Ministry of Justice, Vancouver Crown Law Division, Vancouver

Networking Break        

Mock Cross-Examination of an Expert Witness

  • demonstration and de-brief
  • view from the bench and panel discussion

The Honourable Madam Justice Mary A. Humphries — Supreme Court of BC, Vancouver
David G. Butcher, QC — Wilson Butcher, Vancouver
Jonathan Lawrence, PEng — Director, Senior Engineer, Transportation Group, MEA Forensic Engineers & Scientists, Richmond

Concluding Remarks

Colleen J. Smith — Ministry of Justice, Vancouver Crown Counsel, Vancouver
Graham J. Underwood — Ministry of Justice, Victoria