Suing and Defending the Crown 2018


Course Date: September 14, 2018

Total: 5h 47min

Welcome and Introduction

Joseph J. Arvay, QC — Arvay Finlay LLP, Vancouver
The Honourable Madam Justice Karen A. Horsman — Supreme Court of BC, Vancouver 

Crown Litigation Practice and Procedure 

  • who is the Crown? Naming the proper defendant
  • where to sue? Federal Court v. BCSC
  • collateral attack: when do administrative remedies have to be exhausted? Recent BCCA decision in Greengen

Arden Beddoes — Arvay Finlay LLP, Vancouver
The Honourable Madam Justice Karen A. Horsman — Supreme Court of BC, Vancouver
Donnaree G. Nygard — Department of Justice Canada, Vancouver 

Class Actions Against the Crown 

  • how to sue
  • individual claims v. class actions in litigation against the Crown

Joseph J. Arvay, QC — Arvay Finlay LLP, Vancouver
David A. Klein — Klein Lawyers LLP, Vancouver 

Break

Aboriginal Litigation by and Against the Crown 

  • Origins, categories, and content of Crown/Aboriginal obligations.
  • Practice issues: judicial review or action, proper parties, special rules of evidence, regulatory prosecutions, Federal Court, limitations, pleadings and particulars, experts, emerging causes of action.
  • How should counsel conduct “respectful litigation”?  What is the effect of "honour of the Crown" on the litigation process?

Jack Woodward, QC — Barrister and Solicitor, Campbell River
Paul E. Yearwood — Ministry of Attorney General, Victoria

Lunch (provided) With Featured Speaker: Effective Appellate Advocacy

The Honourable Marshall Rothstein, CC, QC — Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP, Vancouver 

Misfeasance In Public Office: Substantive and Procedural Issues 

  • establishing liability under Category A or B
  • pleadings and evidentiary issues
  • review of J.P. v. British Columbia (Children and Family Development), 2017 BCCA 308

Andrew D. Gay, QC — Gudmundseth Mickelson LLP, Vancouver 

Civil Damages for Charter Breaches 

  • the Ward test and good governance concerns
  • applicability of limitation periods to personal constitutional claims for Charter damages

Jason B. Gratl — Gratl & Company, Vancouver
Jacqueline D. Hughes
 — Ministry of Attorney General, Vancouver

Break

Tort and Charter Remedies For Wrongful Imprisonment 

  • update on Henry v. HMQBC: the trial judgment
  • tort remedies for wrongful imprisonment

Professor Efrat Arbel — Peter A. Allard School of Law, University of BC, Vancouver
Marilyn Sandford, QC — Ritchie Sandford McGowan, Vancouver 

Evidence in Charter Cases: Do/Should Special Rules Apply?

Moderator: Joseph J. Arvay, QC — Arvay Finlay LLP, Vancouver 
Ken Manning
— Department of Justice Canada, Vancouver
Jonathan G. Penner — Ministry of Attorney General, Victoria 
Sheila M. Tucker, QC — Shapray Cramer Fitterman Lamer LLP, Vancouver 

Closing Remarks 

Joseph J. Arvay, QC — Arvay Finlay LLP, Vancouver
The Honourable Madam Justice Karen A. Horsman — Supreme Court of BC, Vancouver