Expert Evidence 2015


Course Date: November 18, 2015

Total: 5h 5min

Welcome and Introduction

Colleen J. SmithMinistry of Justice, Vancouver Crown Counsel, Vancouver
Graham J. UnderwoodMinistry of Justice, Victoria

Expert Evidence: Case Law Update

  • key decisions
  • what you need to know
  • implications for practice

Dianne M. WiedemannMinistry of Justice, Crown Law Division, Vancouver
Graham J. UnderwoodMinistry of Justice, Victoria

The Role of the Expert Witness

  • is an expert witness necessary?
  • when do you need an expert witness?
  • what is the proper sphere of opinion evidence?
  • the ongoing challenge of novel scientific theories

The Honourable Madam Justice Barbara FisherSupreme Court of BC, Vancouver
Richard S. Fowler, QCSmith and Fowler, Vancouver
Catherine L. Woods, QCAlexander Holburn Beaudin + Lang LLP, Vancouver

Networking Break

Retaining and Working with Your Expert Witness

  • considerations in choosing an expert
  • the process of retaining your expert
  • managing communications with your expert
  • the expert report

Wendy E. Dawson, QCMinistry of Justice, New Westminster
Andrew I. NathansonFasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP, Vancouver

Professional and Ethical Issues around Expert Evidence

  • conflicts of interest
  • confidentiality
  • privilege
  • ethics and instructing your expert
  • ensuring expert independence

David LaytonMinistry of Justice, Crown Law Division, Vancouver 

Networking Lunch 

Admissibility—the Big Issue

  • the test for admissibility
  • the gatekeeper role of the trial judge
  • dealing with novel scientific evidence
  • procedural aspects: civil and criminal

Tracey M. CohenFasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP, Vancouver
Peter A. Juk, QCDirector, Appeals & Special Prosecutions, Ministry of Justice, Crown Law Division, Vancouver

Examination of Expert Witnesses: Direct and Cross

  • identifying your goals
  • planning your examination
  • conducting your examination
  • knowing when enough is enough

The Honourable Judge James BahenProvincial Court of BC, Vancouver
Sandra M. KatalinicQA Law, Vancouver
Elliot PollMinistry of Justice, Vancouver Crown Law Division, Vancouver

Networking Break        

Mock Cross-Examination of an Expert Witness

  • demonstration and de-brief
  • view from the bench and panel discussion

The Honourable Madam Justice Mary A. HumphriesSupreme Court of BC, Vancouver
David G. Butcher, QCWilson Butcher, Vancouver
Jonathan Lawrence, PEngDirector, Senior Engineer, Transportation Group, MEA Forensic Engineers & Scientists, Richmond

Concluding Remarks

Colleen J. SmithMinistry of Justice, Vancouver Crown Counsel, Vancouver
Graham J. UnderwoodMinistry of Justice, Victoria